-
Essay / Advantages of Public Shaming as a Punishment
IntroductionPublic shaming is where a criminal is humiliated in public instead of being punished by law or other measures. Shame changed its techniques and arguably produced effective results for minor crimes. Public Shaming uses several tactics, including mental abuse against criminals. People with minor crimes make up the majority of the prison population, and sometimes this is a more logical way to punish them instead of wasting taxpayer dollars. By leaving them alongside violent people, public shaming is a better option. People don't want to be left out; they want to be part of society. Public shaming should be applied in our society and will actually benefit people in the future. Say no to plagiarism. Get a tailor-made essay on “Why Violent Video Games Should Not Be Banned”? Get the original essay. Public humiliation as a punishment has a long history dating back to 1640, when "the Puritans placed people in jail in the town square and were forced to ban them." wear a scarlet letter – or other manifestation of their wrongdoing – to show their shame. »(David Rosen April 2016). Today, public shaming can be used in government, society and sport. In December 2015, Secretary of State John Kerry "invoked the role of public shaming in ensuring that countries comply with the then-recently adopted Paris Agreement on climate change." " In the interview with NBC's Meet the Press, he proclaimed, "There's a lot of promise. There are a lot of promises. But there appears to be no mechanism to get countries to comply, other than pointing fingers and shaming them. Am I wrong? Public shaming can even be used within families. Some parents use public shaming as an alternative to spanking. Some posted videos of their children wearing a sandwich board detailing bad behavior or poor performance on school exams. “Teenagers, especially teenage girls, are being shamed on social media sites like Facebook, Twitter and Vine.” The unanswered question is whether public shaming is a form of cruel and unusual punishment? » Another example is that of sport, in the NFL. The Miami Dolphins had a situation where a player had to quit because he was being harassed by his teammates. On defense, the teammate said it was just a team talk and we were all having fun; but this harassment also took place via SMS. The player is now publicly shamed for harassing his teammate and being racist. Even though he didn't commit a crime, he was very ignorant and that can also be corrected by public shaming. Public shaming has changed its techniques. Social media plays a major role, but it doesn't always turn out to be positive. Shaming criminals was a fundamental part of the American criminal justice system. “While sentences provide hope for the individual, they can also be dehumanizing,” said Professor Mark Osler of St. Thomas University of Law. Another example is that in 1840 there was an accident where a judge intended to convict a man convicted of stealing a pair of pants. The judge told him to sit in the penal colony as punishment. » The penalties of public humiliation began to fade around this time. Although some public shaming punishments such as the pillory continued into the early 1900s, which to some extent worked well for society. Urbanization and migration,historians say, undermined the use of public humiliation because people no longer feared condemnation from their communities. Imprisonment has become the punishment of choice, but states like Pennsylvania and Massachusetts continue to attempt to shame prisoners by allowing the public to observe them “zoo-like.” People argue that the system of imprisoning criminals is nothing more than a way to shame them. Moskos, author of the book "In Defense of Flogging," said in another statement that the idea of humiliating punishments is to give people convicted of minor crimes an alternative to prison.justice in this country and everywhere around of us. A good example is when a judge imposed a shameful sentence. In April 2014, Ohio Municipal Court Judge Gayle Williams ordered Edmond Aviv to remain on the street for five hours with a sign reading. “I’M A BULLY!” I pick on disabled children and can be intolerant of those who are different from me. My actions do not reflect an appreciation of the diversity of the Southern community. Aviv pleaded no contest to the conduct for harassing a neighboring family. We all make mistakes. We are humans and we are not perfect, but there should be consequences for these mistakes. Today, the stakes are higher because of social media. Apologies, regrets, punishments and embarrassments are no longer enough these days. We also have to deal with the court of public opinion and the global network of shame. Public shaming sometimes affects people who don't deserve it, especially the cruelest people on the Internet. A few years ago there was a story about a 13 year old girl. She committed suicide after her father filmed a video of him cutting her hair as punishment. The other example involved a mother in South Carolina who had her son walk around Walmart wearing a tutu and women's underwear with the word "bad" written on his head. I also heard the story from my friends a few weeks ago about a mother who made her children give away all the toys, took pictures of them crying and posted them on Facebook to like them and share them. These are examples of where it is inappropriate to use this tool, and I think it serves as a major contrast to situations where public shaming is useful. Public shaming has negative psychological effects and consequences depending on the sanctions. It can cause depression, suicidal thoughts and mental problems. People who are humiliated can develop various symptoms such as "apathy, paranoia, anxiety and PTSD." Rage can appear in an individual, attacking innocent people. According to the Pew Research Center, 71% of American adults have witnessed online harassment, and 70% of young Americans report being victims themselves and having been subjected to some level of public humiliation. Experts predict that 40% of Americans will be digitally humiliated. If you post or comment online, it does not mean that your post or comment is appropriate. Hiding behind the camera and publicly humiliating people is bad and hurting the people around us is unnecessary. Some people think it's funny, but it's not. Let's not forget that this can lead to suicide and mental problems. Shame can only arise when humiliated inmates blame others. When they did not do this – when they were humiliated, they accepted the blame, the prisoners were no longer likely to fall back into.