-
Essay / Comparison of two articles on architecture - 610
In the history of architecture, there has often been a gap between what the architect wants to design and what the client wants to have. In fact, sometimes an architect makes a great design and gets awards for his design, but maybe the client or user is against it. Stater (2002) and Misra (2002) approach this question in different ways. In the article “it is just not Cricket”, Stater (2002) explains the relationship between the architect and clients in different cases and gives two buildings as examples. The first case that the author shows in this article is the status of the architect who does not speak with anyone and who has knowledge and confidence, while what the client does not like can become secondary. Additionally, the client has different behavioral situations such as inconsistent, unconscious, or most likely indifferent (Stater 2002). On the other hand, he said that the work of the architect is similar to that of the doctor, for example when the patient comes to the general practitioner, he talks to him about his problems and symptoms. As a result, the doctor finds the best treatment and solution to his problems. In the same way, the client comes to the architect and has the same strategies. In terms of negative architectural design, Stater's (2002) explanation can be seen in two example buildings which are Bevin Court and the Media Center at Lord's Cricket Ground. . Although these buildings feature important designs in terms of moderation and technique, they are not functional and present inconveniences to customers. It was for this reason that the architect did not discuss the design with the client (Stater 2002). Conversely, in the article "Whose House Is It? Exploring User Participation in the Design Process of Residences", Misra (2002) explores that the design process must meet the needs of users. Furthermore, the author stated that architecture should be reflected and reinforced by the nature of gender, race and class relations in society. However Misra (2002) discussed four main points in seven projects in India which are the issue of user participation in the design of the built environment, the architectural design process in the case of an individual project is described, and customer involvement, customer models. - user participation is evident and finally some institutional aspects that act systemically to maintain user participation models are highlighted. In the aspect of built environment design, Misra (2002) states that the framework of behavior of individuals and groups is the meaning of the built environment. built environment.